Enamel vs Ceramic Bakeware: Which to Source?

Black enamel steel baking tray, OEM enamel bakeware
執筆者:ティファニー・ライ
ティファニー・ライ

ティファニー・ライ

Bonray Bakewareの共同創設者兼キーアカウントマネージャー

目次

Choose enamel when your brand needs a hard, glass-like surface for roasting trays and ovenware that will be used hard and cleaned hard. It is not truly non-stick, but it is tough, PFAS-free, and backed by LFGB testing. Choose ceramic coating when the priority is easy food release for everyday baking — slick and PFAS-free, but the non-stick surface wears with use and needs gentler care. Both are PFAS-free. The choice is durability and use case, not safety.

That is the short answer. The rest of this guide explains what each coating actually is, how they are made, what the test reports say, and what to ask the factory before you order.

What “enamel” and “ceramic coating” actually mean

The two names sound similar. They are different materials, made in different ways — and buyers confuse them with two other things as well, so let us fix the definitions first.

Enamel bakeware (Bonray) is steel enamel: a glass coating fused onto a steel or iron blank at high temperature. The blank is shaped first, then coated, then fired until the glass melts onto the metal and becomes one hard surface. This is not enamelled cast iron — the heavy Dutch-oven style of enamel. Bonray’s enamel line is steel enamel: roasting trays, baking trays and baking pans. It is lighter, it is made for the oven, and it is the product the test reports in this article cover.

Ceramic coating (Bonray) is a sol-gel silica coating sprayed onto aluminized steel or carbon steel. It is a thin non-stick layer, not a fired ceramic dish. Bonray uses Whitford Fusion® 8088/8089 ceramic coating. For ceramic non-stick, the blank is usually aluminized steel — for example 0.8mm DX53D+AS — which doubles rust resistance compared with plain carbon steel; plain carbon steel (0.8mm DC03) is also available. This is not kiln-fired ceramic tableware, and it is not the same as a ceramic baking dish.

Both coatings contain no PFAS, PTFE or PFOA. That is the point buyers ask about first, and it is true for both — enamel is glass, ceramic coating is silica-based, and neither family is built on fluoropolymers.

Black enamel steel baking tray, OEM enamel bakeware

How Bonray makes enamel: wet process and dry process

Bonray makes enamel bakeware by two processes, and the choice depends on the client’s requirements and the iron blank.

Wet enameling. The steel blank is coated with liquid enamel slip — dipped or flow-coated — and then fired. The slip is a suspension of glass frit, and the firing fuses it to the steel.

Wet enameling: dipping a steel baking tray in enamel slip at the factory

Dry enameling. Dry enamel powder is applied by electrostatic spray onto the blank, and then fired. The charged powder sticks evenly to the metal before the firing melts it into a continuous glass layer.

Dry enameling: electrostatic spray of enamel powder onto baking trays

The enamel material itself comes from TOMATEC, Japan. Bonray stocks TOMATEC enamel paint for the line, and the process — wet or dry — is chosen per product, per the client’s specification and the shape and thickness of the iron blank.

TOMATEC Japan enamel paint drums at the factory

Enamel vs ceramic coating: the comparison

Enamel (steel enamel)Ceramic coating (sol-gel)
What it isGlass fused onto a steel or iron blankSilica-based non-stick layer sprayed onto aluminized steel or carbon steel
SubstrateSteel or iron blank, shaped then coated and firedUsually aluminized steel (DX53D+AS) for ceramic non-stick — doubles rust resistance vs plain carbon steel; carbon steel (DC03) also available
SurfaceHard, glossy, smooth — naturally slick, but not truly non-stickSlick, easy food release — the non-stick option
Food releaseNeeds oil or butter; delicate foods such as eggs release better on ceramicEasy release for cakes, bread and muffins
耐久性Very hard and scratch-resistant; the glass layer is the long-life optionThe non-stick surface wears gradually with use and needs gentler care
What damages itHard knocks and rough metal tools can chip the glass; wood, silicone or nylon tools are saferMetal tools, harsh scouring and overheating shorten the coating’s life
Best forRoasting trays, baking trays and ovenware; acidic foods such as tomato sauces, which the glass surface stands up to wellEveryday baking where release matters: cakes, bread, muffins, sheet pans
Food-contact evidenceIntertek LFGB reports 2025 and 2024 — PASS (see below)Whitford Fusion fact sheet; PPG PFAS declaration; TÜV Rheinland LFGB report — PASS (see below)
PFAS positionNo PFAS, PTFE or PFOA — it is glassNo PFAS intentionally added (PPG declaration, 25 Mar 2025)

What the test reports actually say

A coating claim is only as good as its report. Here is what Bonray can show for each side.

Enamel — third-party testing on the enamel pans supplied. The reports were issued to our enamel factory, Zhongshan Zhuohui Enamel Co., Ltd, and cover the enamel pans in this line:

  • LFGB, Intertek report 250915002GZU-068 (7 Nov 2025) — enamel pan, sensory test and metal-ions release, under §30 and §31 LFGB and Regulation (EC) No 1935/2004. Result: Pass.
  • LFGB, Intertek report 240903009GZU-001 (11 Sep 2024) — enamel pan, same tests, §30 and §31 LFGB. Result: Pass.
  • RoHS, Intertek report 240410093GZU-001 (17 Apr 2024) — RoHS Directive 2011/65/EU and (EU) 2015/863.
  • REACH, Intertek report 240410093GZU-005 (18 Apr 2024) — 249 substances of very high concern (SVHCs), each below 0.1% by weight, under EU REACH Regulation 1907/2006 Article 33(1).

Ceramic coating — the coating system and its evidence. Bonray’s ceramic coating is Whitford Fusion® 8088/8089. PPG, the coating maker, declared on 25 March 2025 that PFAS is not intentionally added to Fusion products N213206, N213207 and N212248. A non-stick carbon steel turkey roaster with this type of coating passed LFGB testing — TÜV Rheinland report 302105150a 001, conclusion Pass — and REACH SVHC testing covers the non-stick coating range (TÜV Thüringen report 8621.SHJ1.2504.0422, 5 July 2025). Full reports are available on request, with the report number and date that match your product.

Two wording notes, because buyers check them: there is no such thing as “FDA approved” cookware — the correct claim is FDA-compliant, substance by substance. And “PFOA-free” is not the same as “PFAS-free”: PFOA is one substance, PFAS is the whole family. Ask for the PFAS position in writing.

What to ask the factory before you order

Use this checklist in your RFQ. A factory that answers all six, with documents, is a factory you can buy from.

  1. Which substrate and thickness? For coated pans: carbon steel (for example 0.8mm DC03) or aluminized steel (DX53D+AS)? For enamel: which iron blank, and why?
  2. Which coating system, and whose? TOMATEC enamel, or Whitford Fusion ceramic — name the system, not just “ceramic” or “enamel”.
  3. Wet or dry enamel — and why for this pan? The process should follow the product and the blank, not the factory’s convenience.
  4. Which food-contact documents come with the order? Ask for the LFGB report number and date, plus REACH and RoHS, and check the report covers your exact product.
  5. What is the sample plan? Regular samples are ready within 5 days; custom samples need mould development, typically 25–35 days. Order the sample before the bulk order.
  6. What are the MOQ and lead time? Bonray’s standard MOQ is typically 500 pieces per product, and lead time is 4–6 weeks. Confirm both in writing for your size and colour.

Frequently asked questions

Is enamel bakeware PFAS-free?

Yes. Enamel is glass fused to steel — it contains no PFAS, PTFE or PFOA. Ceramic sol-gel coatings are also PFAS-free; PPG has declared that PFAS is not intentionally added to the Fusion ceramic coatings Bonray uses. Both sides are backed by the third-party reports listed above.

Which lasts longer, enamel or ceramic coating?

Enamel has the edge on longevity. The fused glass layer is hard and scratch-resistant, and with proper care it is the long-life option. Ceramic coating releases food more easily, but its non-stick surface wears gradually with use, so it suits everyday baking where easy release matters most and gentler care is realistic.

Can I get the test reports with my order?

Yes. LFGB, RoHS and REACH reports are available on request — ask for the report number and date that match your product, and keep them with your compliance file for the EU or UK market.

About Bonray

Bonray has made OEM bakeware in China since 2014 — 12 years, 100+ brands supplied, and a standard MOQ of typically 500 pieces per product. Our bakeware coatings are ceramic, silicone non-stick and PTFE, plus the steel enamel line in this article, and our enamel bakeware has been supplied to international restaurant and retail brands, including Pizza Hut. Samples are ready within 5 days for regular items, custom samples take 25–35 days for mould development, and lead time is 4–6 weeks.

If you are choosing between enamel and ceramic coating for your next range, send us the size, the use case and the market — we will recommend the coating, the process and the documents, and send a sample first. See our Quality & Certifications and our ベーキングシート そして パン型 ranges, or read our companion guide, Carbon Steel vs Aluminum Bakeware: Which to Source?

投稿タグ :
共有 :

史上最高のベーキングウェアを体験してください

最新の市場レポートを入手してください!

完璧な耐熱皿ソリューションを見つけてください。